Published by StreetSmartLive.com

April 23, 2006

Chief Editor: Greg Arnold
Featured Contributing Columnist: Ted Nicholas
Contributing Editors: Tom "Big Al" Schreiter, Robert Butwin, Jeffery Combs,
Jerry "DRhino" Clark, Todd Falcone, Artemis Limpert, Ellie Drake, Dr Stan Harris & Jeff Babener

Stay Informed with the Street Smart Live Toolbar.  Click on this image for details:

Back

What Is MLM? My Biased View 

By Gerald P. Nehra, MLM Attorney
 

Gerry Nehra, MLM Legal Specialist
Many direct sales companies or their distributors choose to avoid the MLM (multilevel marketing) label, or deny they are MLM. One reason might be that most companies today no longer have a multi-level form of distribution, the kind where certain ranks of distributors buy direct from the company, and re-sell to lower ranks of distributors and to customers. The more efficient distribution model is for the company to directly fulfill orders to the end user consumer. This method is now the norm, not the exception. So it may be accurate to say that companies structured that way do not have a multilevel form of distribution. But most of these companies still have a multi-level form of compensation. My position has always been that if you have a multi-level form of compensation – the multi-level and anti-pyramid laws apply. Those laws apply even if the company literature never uses MLM language, and even if the company or its independent contractor distributors deny, verbally or in writing, that the company or its distributors engage in multilevel marketing. So where is the line? Here is my position, for what it is worth:

IF the independent contractor income opportunity is limited to the potential to RECEIVE income from the company, ONLY by your purchases (for your personal and family consumption and/or for resale) AND by the purchases of persons you DIRECTLY INTRODUCE to the company (no matter what these purchasers are called) – the company has offered a single-level income opportunity to independent contractors, and is NOT multi-level. The income opportunity offered by the company becomes multi-level when the potential to receive income GOES BEYOND what I have just written above. So, if the compensation plan rewards you when the people that you introduce, introduce more people who buy products – we have a multi-level form of compensation. At this point you are being rewarded for MORE THAN the business volume YOU personally generate – and are additionally being rewarded for business volume being generated by persons a level away from you – thus – multi-level.

The same line of demarcation, using different words, follows: “Income opportunity,” of course, means the opportunity to receive income. In the single level model, you (singly) control that flow of income to you. You do so by placing the orders for business volume yourself, and by being the “consumer finder” of consumers placing orders. The flow of money below you in the hierarchy (assuming the company places the consumers in a hierarchy, as some companies do) is only TOWARDS the company in the form of payment for products (or services.) If there is, or can be, a flow of money FROM the company to persons below you in the hierarchy, then those persons are independent contractors, instead of, or in addition to, being consumers. Since you were empowered to recruit, sponsor, or refer those people, and since the compensation plan, in addition to rewarding those people below you for their business volume, most likely also rewards you a percentage – we have a “multilevel” form of compensation.

A third take at it: When the only way you, as an independent contractor, can make money with the company is by generating business volume (yourself) you are participating in a single level income opportunity. If however, you are given two ways to make money – generate business volume – and optionally – find, (sponsor, recruit, refer) other independent contractors who generate business volume – you are participating in a multilevel income opportunity. The key is that the independent contractors are empowered to find, and rewarded for finding, additional independent contractors. That is the very definition (legal definition) of “multilevel.” A footnote type comment is necessary here. The “rewarded for” above, can only be an indirect reward based on the business volume of the second independent contractor. It can never be an immediate reward for just finding the person. Such an immediate reward is referred to as a “head hunting fee” and is pyramidal and illegal.

So where in the law is “multilevel” defined? Actually a definition appears in very few places, which will be discussed below. Before doing so, let me state that prohibitions against paying a participant to bring you another participant, and paying a company for the right to bring in more participants, exist in over 40 of the 50 states, without any mention of “multilevel.”

I am not aware of “multilevel” being mentioned or defined in any Federal statute. Five states and Puerto Rico do mention and attempt to define “multilevel.” Let’s take a look: Three situations are identical and easy to deal with. In the laws of Georgia, Massachusetts and Wyoming, the “multilevel” definitions include the operative words “participants may recruit other participants.” Clearly the flow of products directly to end users, or through “levels” does not matter. What matters is the right to sponsor. Puerto Rico gets to the same place with different language – “to dealers who serve as intermediaries to enlist other dealers.” With four of the six jurisdictions quite clear, we look at Montana. The statute is poorly drafted, but does contain language about both the levels of distribution of products, and about recruiting:

(3) (a) "Multilevel distribution company" means a person that:
(i) sells, distributes, or supplies goods or services through independent agents, contractors, or distributors at different levels of distribution;
(ii) may recruit other participants in the company; and
(iii) is eligible for commissions, cross-commissions, override commissions, bonuses, refunds, dividends, or other consideration that is or may be paid as a result of the sale of goods or services or the recruitment of or the performance or actions of other participants.

You may draw your own conclusion. I conclude that a right to recruit makes you multilevel by this Montana definition. And finally we get to Maryland. The Maryland statute makes no mention of the right to sponsor or recruit more participants. At last, a basis for saying “We are not MLM” even if it is only in one state. The definition is below.

In this subtitle, "multilevel distribution company" means a person who, for consideration, distributes goods or services through independent agents, contractors, or distributors at different levels of distribution with rates of pricing or discounting that differ from 1 level to another.

My conclusion – Most should take “We are not MLM” out of their vocabulary, if the company, or the program they are working – offers two ways to make money – bring in business volume – and find others who will do the same, and receive an additional reward on their efforts. Two exceptions – if you only operate in Maryland and do not distribute through levels – or - if you truly are “single-level,” meaning NO compensation based on the business volume of independent contractors you introduce.

Gerald P. Nehra is an MLM-specialist, private practice attorney. He is one of only a few attorneys nationwide whose practice is devoted exclusively to direct selling and multilevel marketing issues. His 35 years of legal experience includes nine years at Amway Corporation, where he was Director of the Legal Division. He can be reached at 1710 Beach Street, Muskegon, Michigan 49441, 231-755-3800. His e-mail address is GNehra@mlmatty.com. You are invited to visit his web site at www.mlmatty.com.

 

Why the MLM Cruise is the most powerful tool in the industry!
 

Now is the time to reserve your balcony cabin for two!

The Seminar at Sea is one of the very best tools in the MLM industry because; Over the years this cruise has become the root of most of my annual income.  Virtually every contact I have outside my own company has either come from this cruise or been introduced to me by someone I met on this cruise.

I won't tell you how much money I will make in 2006 as the result of networking with these super contacts, but I will tell you it will be in the six figures.   They say that your income will generally be somewhere near that of the people you hang out with.  I can tell you from experience that this is true.  Probably because if you hang out with people like Big Al, Robert Butwin, Ken Seto, and Art Jonak  long enough, it will so raise your expectations, you won't be able to help but raise your income level too! 

Between networking with the best of the best and attending the onboard seminars, you just can't beat it.  The life long friends and contacts you will make on this cruise can help make you a fortune.  Why are the best of the best attracted to this cruise year after year?  Because they know!  November 12th through the 19th - "Big Al" MLM Training Cruise -This year’s 7 day cruise leaves from San Juan, Puerto Rico to St. Thomas, to Dominica, to Barbatos, to Aruba and back to San Juan!  Book Early because this cruise sells out EVERY YEAR!

More Information About The MLM Cruise!

FREE New Ebook
Inside The Mind of the MLM Masters

With contributions from Robert Butwin, Jerry Clark, Jeffery Combs, Rod Cook, Tom "Big Al" Schreiter, Ellie Drake, Artemis Limpert, Ken Seto, Greg Arnold and Todd Falcone.  This group of industry experts have teamed up to bring you one of the most powerful Ebooks ever assembled!

Click Here to find out how to get yours FREE!

© 2005, 2006 http://www.streetsmartlive.com
Street Smart Live Newsletter
PO Box 1104, Carson WA  98610


Greg Arnold and Robert Butwin have teamed up to bring you the Street Smart Live MLM Newsletter. 


Ted Nicholas, legendary direct marketer, entrepreneur and best-selling author, has personally marketed over 4 Billion Dollars worth of products and services through space ads, sales letters, T.V., radio, the Internet and from the platform.


Tom "Big Al" Schreiter is the author of the Fortune Now Newsletter, a generic training resource for professional network marketing leaders.


Jerry “DRhino” Clark  is one of the true "superstars" of the MLM industry. He is Committed to Educating, Equipping, and Empowering Network Marketers World Wide.


Jeffery Combs is an internationally recognized speaker, trainer, and author whose training revolves around personal growth and development and delivers information that makes an immediate impact on your success!


Todd Falcone has been a successful field leader for over a decade.  He is also a public speaker, trainer and personal coach to several top producing network marketers.


Highly successful MLM Distributor, Artemis Limpert is an EAS Body-for-Life © Grand Champion for the year 2000 and her personal achievements led to her being selected as a current spokesperson for Anthony Robbins latest infomercial “Get the Edge”.


Ellie Drake is the President and CEO of BraveHeart Productions. She is a Keynote Speaker, Coach, Doctor, and Successful Entrepreneur.


Dr. Stan Harris is the present reigning champion of Karate World Rating System, a member of the Black Belt Hall of Fame, a member of the Motivational Speakers Hall of Fame, Author, powerful speaker, AND VERY SUCCESSFUL ENTREPRENEUR!


Over the last two decades Jeff Babener has served as marketing and legal advisor to some of the world's largest direct selling companies, the likes of Avon, Nikken, Shaklee, Tupperware, Prepaid Legal, Longaberger, Melaleuca, Discovery Toys, Amazon Herb, NuSkin, Cell Tech, New Vision and Sunrider.